| Character | Cast A | Cast B |
| Jennie | MacKenzie Watkins | Alexandra Harvey |
| Jessie | Allison Watkins | Megan Scott |
| Mrs. Umney | Rachel Buchanan | Natalie Woods |
| Lady Canterville | Michelle Stringer | Ashley Isaacs |
| Weeds | Alexander Jung | Johnathan Herron |
| Pam | Rebecca Watkins | Kim Force |
| Wendy | Lindsay Podrid | Monica Wajsman |
| Mrs. Otis (Lucy) | Valerie Watkins | Lee Ann Mitchell |
| Mr. Otis (Horace) | Bill Fleming | Chuck Coleman |
| Virginia | Laurin Nutt | Sara Gaare |
| Sir Simon | Zach Bosteel | Alex Herron |
| Vicar | Jeremy Mabe | Josh Katz |
| Lord Cecil | Tim Morin | Michael McHugh |
| Mrs. Dampier | Leslie Henderson | Sara English |
| Madam Balaklava | Kristen McKee | Lauren Burdett |
| Martin the Maniac | Nathaniel Watkins | Nicholas Jenkins |
| Herbert the Horrible | Mike Morin | Alex Jaracz |
| Lady Joan the Graveless | Andrea Ashby | Jenny Wyrick |
| Vampire Duchess | Megan McGarity | Holly Hansen |
| Mrs. Midwinter | Hannah Moore | Sara Scott |
| Mrs. Musgrave | Kira Stringer | Lindsey Dysert |
