| CHARACTER |
CAST A |
CAST B |
 |
 |
|
| Fern | Melanie Sheahan | Nicole Schlabach |
| John Arable | Cody Richey | Andrew Fennell |
| Martha Arable | Maddie Russo | Laura Pisano |
| Avery | David Wittes | Wilson Robinson |
| Homer Zuckerman | Jack Schatz | Nico Villanueva |
| Edith Zuckerman | Rachel Mango | Kaleigh Fitzgerald |
| Lurvy | Joe Bryant | Justin Fedich |
| Wilbur | David Axford | Liam Sullivan |
| Templeton | Kellen Flatt | James Murphy |
| Charlotte | Abby Holland | Maggie Whitworth |
| Goose | Emmie Axford | Cayla Franzman |
| Gander | Ryan Talley | Amy Ward |
| Sheep | Erin Fisher | Laura Kinney |
| Lamb | Dylan Borst | Natalie Fennell |
| (*) Cow | Macy Lang | Audra Bailey |
| (*) Horse | Cori Vance | Rebecca Fields |
| (*) Hen | Rachel Jeffs | Bennett Welch |
| (*) Rooster | Leslie Sandor | Emily Brittain |
| (*) Cat | Kayla Crowell | Angela Delaney |
| (*) Dog | Elizabeth Eyrich | Mary Grace Keilhauer |
| Reporter | Mackenzie Martin | Morgan Reynolds |
| Photographer | Laila Treadwell | Rebecca Neuman |
| Spectator 1 | Mackenzie Martin | Hannah Delaney |
| Spectator 2 | Ashley Odom | Laura Seidman |
| Fairgoer 1 | Ashley Odom | Hannah Delaney |
| Fairgoer 2 | Laila Treadwell | Laura Seidman |
| Fairgoer 3 | Sam Bryant | Rebecca Neuman |
| Announcer | Mackenzie Martin | Morgan Reynolds |
| Uncle Pig | Sam Bryant | Nico Villanueva |
| Spider 1 | Laila Treadwell | Angela Delaney |
| Spider 2 | David Wittes | Wilson Robinson |
| Spider 3 | Mackenzie Martin | Rebecca Neuman |
| Voice Over | Laila Treadwell | Rebecca Neuman |
| Judge | Ashley Odom | Laura Seidman |
| Judge | Laila Treadwell | Hannah Delaney |
| Judge | Mackenzie Martin | Morgan Reynolds |